OVERVIEW:
An epistolary novel, the reader receives letter after letter from Charlie, a ninth grade teen with an abounding curiosity and a crippling understanding of relationships. Although he is a sweet heart, Charlie is told up front by his crush, Sam, that she is too old for him and should not allow his feelings to get the better of him. He'll try, but of course emotions and love are never that simple. The torment and complexity of love, friendship and family are expressed in his letters--letters that reveal a dangerously troubled mind and anxious denial of the painful truth. In his attempts to overcome his vaguely described problem--one that sent him to the doctor as a child and has teachers still carefully observing his every move--Charlie seeks comfort and acceptance from his misguided friends. And while their kindness and true affection dull the pain, their own troubles might reawaken something he dearly hoped to forget.
RATING: (4 out of 5)
This story is a very emotional and provocative text. Charlie's thoughts are so rich and relatable for teens, especially though struggling with anxiety, depression, finding acceptance. However, not all teens may be able to empathize with the intelligent strait A tormented student. This text is definitely for highly mature readers on account of language, topics, and themes. I would not give this to my middle school child, and possibly not even my young high school child. I think 11th or 12th grade would be a safer age to suggest this text, but I would certainly advice caution to the reader about what is in store.
TO PARENTS:
As noted above, I do not think this is an acceptable text for middles school aged students. This text is consistent in foul language and sexual topics. Such sexual topics addressed are teen sexuality, teen sexual activity (including masturbation), abusive relationship, teen pregnancy, abortion, teen substance abuse, rape/molestation, depression and anxiety. I highly recommend taking the time to read this text before concluding to give this to your young reader, especially if you have any qualms or concerns. This text can really provide insight to the dark and painful truths of teens trapped in unhealthy relationships and habits, as well as the cognitive stressors mentors and parents might be unawares of. My feelings are very mixed about this book, but I found this text to be an impactful experience.
No comments:
Post a Comment